You haven't. But you might be predisposed to not being disappointed by someone with this face and name. Maybe you've got it in your head that you're correcting a mistake.

I don't think you'd do it deliberately. You may have been a cruel man in the past, but you aren't one now. I trust you enough that you wouldn't try to hurt me or anyone you give a damn about.

[But now that he knows, he has to know:] What do you see when you look at me? Who do you see?